Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras announced Sunday night that Greece's banks
would be closed as of Monday, as the fallout from ruptured debt
negotiations with the nation's creditors began inflicting pain on
ordinary people while raising alarm in Washington, Brussels and Berlin.
The emergency measures escalated the confused and unpredictable state of
a crisis that some analysts say could ripple through global financial
markets and undercut European unity.
With so much at stake, leaders in other capitals encouraged a continued
search for a way to prevent Greece from being forced out of Europe's
currency union. Greece owes a large debt payment by the end of the day
Tuesday, and has scheduled a referendum for next Sunday on whether to
accept terms of an offer from its creditors to release bailout aid it
needs to meet its financial obligations.
Tsipras
announced the emergency banking shutdown, which will also close the
stock exchange, and imposed capital controls several hours after the
European Central Bank said it would not expand an emergency loan program
that had been propping up Greek banks for weeks. The banking system had
neared insolvency after panicked account holders withdrew billions of
euros, a pattern that continued over the weekend.
"It is clearer than ever that this decision has no other goal than
blackmailing the Greek people and obstructing the smooth democratic
procedure of the referendum," Tsipras said in a brief televised address.
Tsipras attributed the action to the unwillingness of the country's
creditors to extend the bailout program, set to end Tuesday, until next
Sunday, so that Greece could hold its national referendum. The
referendum was a surprise move by Tsipras, announced early Saturday, as
he declared that voters should decide whether to accept the terms of the
creditors' latest aid proposal - terms he considers onerous.
Greece's creditors - the other 18 eurozone countries, the ECB and the
International Monetary Fund - in effect cut off negotiations with
Tsipras after he called for the referendum, raising concerns that Greece
would default on its debt and potentially seek to solve its financial
problems by abandoning the euro.
But on Sunday, international leaders appeared to be seeking a way to
calm the situation and explore the potential for common ground with the
Greek government.
President Barack Obama and Chancellor Angela Merkel of Germany spoke by
phone Sunday and "agreed that it was critically important to make every
effort to return to a path that will allow Greece to resume reforms and
growth within the eurozone," according to the White House. Merkel was
expected to make a public statement Monday in Berlin.
Christine Lagarde, managing director of the IMF, who has at times been
sharply critical of Greece's negotiating stance, released a softer
statement, declaring her "commitment to continue to engage with the
Greek authorities."
Greece must make a 1.6 billion euro debt payment to the IMF on Tuesday or risk falling into default.
Before this weekend, the four-month negotiations focused on the Greek
side trying to agree to fiscal reforms, tax increases and pension cuts
in exchange for creditors releasing a 7.2 billion euro bailout allotment
that Greece needs to meet its short-term debt obligations, equivalent
to about $8.1 billion. Tsipras had consistently called for a broader,
comprehensive deal that would liberate Greece from the economics of
austerity. Attention will now likely shift to Brussels and Berlin.
In Brussels, the European Commission made its own unexpected moves
Sunday. Jean-Claude Juncker, the commission president, released a
statement suggesting that creditors had been willing to discuss Greece's
debt load, a key demand of the Tsipras government. But more
surprisingly, the commission published details of the offer made to
Greece, a move intended to show the lengths to which creditors had gone
to satisfy Greek demands, one European Union official said.
"This is a last bridge we are building for them," the official said
about the decision to publish the terms of proposal. The goal was to
pressure Tsipras to "change course" and encourage voters to choose
"yes"' in the coming referendum, the official said, while acknowledging
the chances for such a switch were slim.
Perhaps the key figure in finding a compromise, assuming there is still
time to do so, is Merkel, the most powerful political figure in Europe.
She remained silent Sunday, with officials saying that Wolfgang
Schauble, the German finance minister, spoke for the government in
Brussels on Saturday. Following the collapse of talks, the finance
minister declared that Germany and the other members of the euro would
like to continue to hold talks but blamed the Greeks for declaring the
discussions a failure.
But Schauble also indicated readiness to "do everything to prevent every
possible threat of contagion" of the situation, should Greece fail to
reach a deal with its creditors, reflecting growing frustration in
Berlin with the government in Athens.
Norbert Rottgen, a senior member of Chancellor Merkel's party who is
responsible for foreign affairs, stressed the wider geopolitical
implications of what he called a "vagabond Greek government," which
could say no to the next round of European sanctions against Russia. He
warned that after five years of bailouts, "it cannot just collapse over a
week."
The immediate question in Greece revolved around the specifics of the
emergency actions announced by Tsipras. He did not mention the stock
market in his public address, but a senior official confirmed that it
would also close.
The prime minister indicated that restrictions would be placed on ATM
withdrawals and money transfers, but he provided no details. A
legislative decree said banks would be closed through July 6 and that
the cap on daily cash machine withdrawals would be 60 euros. That would
not apply to tourists using cards issued in their home countries.
Such a small cash withdrawal limit would highlight the dire condition of
the Greek banking system. Cyprus avoided a banking collapse in 2013 by
taking similar steps, though the daily withdrawal limit was 300 euros.
The Cypriot government also acted in concert with other European
governments as part of a new bailout program, while the Greek actions
were the result of a breakdown in bailout talks.
The ECB, if refusing to expand emergency funds to Greek banks, did not
cut off support entirely, which will provide the government some
flexibility in the coming days.
The ECB's decision to cap the emergency loan program, as opposed to
canceling it, "allows the Greek banks to remain in a sort of coma - not
functioning but not dead," said Karl Whelan, an economics professor at
University College in Dublin. That way, he said, the Greek financial
system might be revived if Greece secures a deal with its creditors.
And several analysts still predicted that despite the confrontation and
fireworks, the two sides might well return to the table. Even as Tsipras
and other members of his government are imploring people to vote "no"
in the referendum and reject the creditors' proposal, some experts
predict that Greek voters, equating such a vote with leaving the euro
system, will vote "yes."
Raoul Ruparel, an economist and co-director of Open Europe, a
London-based research group, said the breakdown in negotiations was
"merely a prelude" to yet more talks in a week or so, after Greece holds
its referendum.
"I think we are just getting started on this merry-go-round," said
Ruparel, predicting that Greek voters would probably vote to endorse
proposals put forward by creditors. "We would then be back where we
started, only in a worse situation."
He predicted that Tsipras' government and the creditors would need to
negotiate an entirely new, and probably short-term, bailout in an
atmosphere poisoned by even deeper distrust than before.
(www.ndtv.com)